Opening: The charge and the response delivered in a single breath.

The charge being made is that “Islam, along with the Qur’an and prophetic teachings, is inconsistent regarding spiritual growth and self-improvement.”

The straightforward response to this accusation is that what may seem like a contradiction often stems from a misreading, a misunderstanding of different levels of meaning, or a failure to recognize the Qur’an’s organic method. This is not an actual contradiction.

The Divine teachings deliberately combine elements such as firmness and mercy, law and inner transformation, universal principles and contextual rulings, as well as destiny and responsibility. This approach reflects the complexity of human beings.

When we examine the texts within their literary, theological, moral, and psychological contexts, the perceived inconsistencies transform into a coherent and dynamic pedagogy for the soul.

In this text, I will outline the main points critics raise, explain why these critiques are mistaken, and provide a practical plan for readers to not only understand the defense intellectually but also to apply it in practice.

“Predestination versus responsibility” — the timeless debate.

The objection is: If God has decreed everything, how can humans strive, repent, or be praised and blamed?

Refutation (scriptural + rational):

  • The Qur’an emphasizes both divine decree and human responsibility. It repeatedly encourages people to transform themselves, as seen in the verse, “Allah will not change the condition of a people until they change what is in themselves.” (Qur’an 13:11). At the same time, it acknowledges God’s knowledge and decree over all things. These concepts are not contradictory but rather complementary truths that address different aspects of reality: God’s omniscience and providence on one hand, and human moral responsibility and education on the other.
  • A teacher who understands a pupil’s abilities and future potential can still demand effort and hold the pupil accountable. Knowing outcomes and requiring effort are not mutually exclusive.
  • The Qur’an’s educational approach emphasizes responsibility: its commands, promises, and warnings imply that individuals have agency. If humanity were completely passive, these messages would lack significance. Therefore, theology does not reject moral agency; instead, it positions agency within a framework of trust: we take action, while God sustains and ultimately perfects what is right.

For those seeking guidance: Embrace both truths—trust in God’s wisdom (tawakkul) while also making persistent and purposeful efforts (mujāhadah). This represents the prophetic balance.

“External Rituals vs. Inner Transformation” — Are practices simply a form of ritualism?

Islam prioritizes outward acts such as prayer, fasting, and ablution, yet it appears indifferent to the necessity of inner transformation, which can lead to hypocrisy.

Refutation (historical + theological):

  • The Qur’an and the Prophet (peace be upon him) consistently connect outward acts of worship with inner states of being. Rituals serve as tools designed to refine the heart. Islamic law (Sharīʿah) provides a structured framework for behaviour, while spirituality (Tariqah / akhlāq) nurtures the heart. These two aspects are complementary, as many classical scholars, particularly Imam al-Ghazali in his work Iḥyâ’, have explained: outward actions act as the medicine, while spiritual training serves as the cure.
  • Far from being indifferent, the Qur’an criticizes rituals that are performed insincerely; it reproaches those who engage in rites while their hearts remain unreceptive. The suggested remedy is twofold: perform the act correctly and seek inner presence.

For those seeking guidance: Use external practices intentionally—make prayer, fasting, and charity opportunities for honest self-reflection and for developing attention and compassion.

“Instant illumination versus gradual discipline” — which approach does Islam prefer?

The Qur’an describes sudden guidance and patient growth. Are these inconsistent prescriptions?

Refutation (Psychological and Spiritual):

  • Human spiritual change can occur in both sudden and gradual ways. The Qur’an and Sunna describe these two experiences: a person may experience an immediate conviction (hidayah) or may be guided through consistent practice over time. While these modes are different, they complement each other. A sudden experience often requires disciplined practice afterward to develop fully, while a dedicated path can also lead to sudden insights.
  • The Divine method is wise: it requires both the open door of mercy and the ladder of effort. For many, God’s guiding light first softens the heart; then, ongoing practice solidifies the change.

For those seeking guidance: Accept sudden insights with gratitude, but cultivate habits to ensure that this grace becomes a stable part of your life.

“Mercy versus warnings — inconsistent tone.”

The Qur’an can be mild and merciful at times, while at other times, it is severe and threatening. Which portrayal is accurate?

counterargument

  • The rhetoric of the Qur’an is purposefully varied: mercy to attract, and warning to awaken. This is similar to a physician who uses encouragement or firm advice depending on the patient’s condition. Mercy softens the resistant heart, while warnings shake the heedless.
  • The teacher’s role is to both console and admonish students. The Qur’an’s variety of tones reflects its psychological depth, not its contradictions.

Practical advice for the seeker: Do not be discouraged by warnings; view them as calls to reform. Accept mercy as motivation to not squander the gift.

“Knowledge versus Action: Why teach knowledge if action is inconsistent?”

The Qur’an values knowledge, yet many knowledgeable individuals act immorally. Does knowledge truly hold significance?

counterargument

  • Knowledge (ʿilm) without action (‘amal) is incomplete. The Qur’an values both knowledge and action, praising those who possess both and criticizing those who only engage in empty rhetoric. The Islamic intellectual tradition—from the Companions to Al-Ghazali and beyond—emphasizes that the true purpose of knowledge is to bring about transformation.
  • Furthermore, knowledge is essential to guide effort. Without understanding, efforts can be misdirected. Therefore, knowledge and action are two wings of the same flight.

Pursue knowledge with humility and apply new learning through small, disciplined practices.

“Universal moral ideals versus context-sensitive judgments.”

The objection states that while the Qur’an provides timeless principles, it also includes specific laws intended for a particular community, which critics argue is inconsistent.

Refutation (jurisprudential and pragmatic):

  • Every legal system applies general principles to specific situations. The Qur’an establishes enduring objectives such as justice, mercy, and human dignity, while also allowing for detailed rulings that address these goals in particular contexts. Jurisprudence (fiqh) represents the human endeavour to apply divine principles to evolving circumstances. The differences among jurists arise from the variety of contexts rather than from contradictions in the core message.
  • The Qur’an’s legislation serves a purpose: it aims to secure the moral and material well-being of individuals and societies. Specific rulings are not antagonistic to this universal aim; rather, they function as tools to achieve it.

Practical advice for seekers: Understand the ethical principles behind rulings; focus on both the spirit and the letter.

A brief theological synthesis: Understanding why the Qur’anic method is coherent.

  1. The Qur’an addresses intellect, will, heart, and society differently. A passage aimed at the heart may differ significantly from one focused on law; this diversity represents a methodological approach.
  2. Rituals, rules, knowledge, repentance, and divine grace are tools aimed at one goal: refining the human soul and creating righteous communities.
  3. Dynamic pedagogy: The Divine Teacher combines encouragement and comfort, immediate insights and extended discipline, personal responsibility and communal frameworks—because humans are intricate beings who need a diverse education.

Practical Mobilization Program (in the prophetic, Hazur-like spirit)

Do not let this remain a theoretical defence. The best refutation of the claim “Islam is inconsistent” is a lived transformation. Start with a compact daily program:

  1. Morning self-accounting — 5 minutes: ask, “Where did I fail yesterday? What concrete step can I take to rectify this?”
  2. Daily small acts, stored like seeds: commit to one tiny, repeatable deed (2 minutes of focused dhikr or one extra act of kindness). Small repetitions fuel the formation of habits.
  3. Knowledge in action: study a short text or verse and write one sentence on how to apply it practically.
  4. Engage in weekly community service to foster spiritual growth; humility and action support one another.
  5. Repentance and resolve: when you fail, practice immediate tawbah and create a specific plan to avoid the same mistake next time.
  6. Patience and prayer are essential; seek help from both. The Qur’an explicitly instructs us to seek assistance through patience and prayer (Q. 2:153).
  7. Mentorship: seek a guide, elder, or friend—spiritual growth involves both social and personal aspects.

Closing exhortation — a rousing conclusion.

Dear friends, the Qur’an does not contradict itself; rather, it conveys messages in various tones that resonate with different hearts. Any apparent contradictions disappear when we view the Book as a living curriculum for the soul—a curriculum that diagnoses, prescribes, treats, warns, consoles, and empowers.

If anyone claims that Islam is inconsistent regarding spiritual growth, encourage them to experience the practice rather than engage in a debate. Invite them to pray with focus, fast with intention, serve with love, learn with humility, repent sincerely, and persevere with patience. They will witness the transformation. The most powerful response is a reformed heart.

May Allah guide us to be workers of spiritual renewal—practical, humble, and constant. May He make us among those for whom effort becomes guidance, and guidance becomes inner light. Ameen.

If you want, I can now transform this into a short sermon (5–7 minutes) with cues for voice, pauses, and Qur’anic recitations — or render it in Bengali in the style of Humayun Ahmed or Hazrat Mirza Tahir Ahmad. Which would you prefer next?

Leave a Comment